Politics
States Predict Inmates’ Future Crimes with Secretive Surveys

In this photo taken Nov. 13, 2014, a guard tower on the fence line at North Central Unit at Calico Rock, Ark. The unit is where Milton Thomas is currently confined prior to his upcoming trial, expected to be held in March 2015. He is charged with raping Diana Miller, 71-year-old former nurse and Navy veteran. Thomas was on parole when he was arrested for raping Miller. (AP Photo/Bill Gorman)
EILEEN SULLIVAN, Associated Press
RONNIE GREENE, Associated Press
LITTLE ROCK, Ark. (AP) — On a hot Friday last July, a parolee was mowing a lawn in a small cul-de-sac on the west side of the city when he stopped to ask for a glass of water.
The 70-year-old widow whose yard he was mowing told him to wait on her porch. Instead, she said, he jerked the storm door open, slammed her against the wall, forced her into the bedroom and raped her. The parolee pushed her with such force, she said, that her front teeth were knocked loose.
Then he went back to mowing the lawn.
Milton Thomas, 58, said he’s not guilty. His trial is set for March.
Thomas has been in and out of Arkansas prisons since 2008 for nonviolent crimes, including check fraud. After he got out in November 2013, the state predicted he was a low risk to commit another crime, Thomas said, and assigned him the least amount of supervision.
His low-risk prediction would have been calculated based on answers to a lengthy questionnaire, the latest tool among the nation’s court systems to try to predict the likelihood that an offender will commit a crime again.
Across the country, states have turned to a data-driven movement to drive down prison populations, reduce recidivism and save billions of dollars. One emerging practice is the use of risk-and-needs assessment tools, which are questionnaires that explore issues beyond criminal history. They are based on surveys of offenders making their way through the justice system.
In a country with the highest incarceration numbers in the world, these questionnaires are a pillar of a new effort to get people out of prison. Repeat offenders are a major driver of bloated prison populations. But an Associated Press examination found significant problems with the surveys, which are used inconsistently across the United States, sometimes within the same jurisdiction.
Supporters cite some research, such as a 1987 Rand Corp. study that said the surveys can be up to 70 percent accurate in predicting the likelihood of repeat offenses, if they are used correctly. Even the Rand study, one of the seminal pieces of research on the subject, was skeptical of the surveys’ effectiveness.
It’s nearly impossible to measure the surveys’ impact on recidivism because they are only part of broader efforts.
These assessment surveys, used for crimes ranging from petty thievery to serial murders, come with their own set of risks.
Many rely on criminals to tell the truth, though jurisdictions do not always check to make sure the answers are accurate.
The surveys are clouded in secrecy. Some states never release the evaluations, shielding government officials from being held accountable for decisions that affect public safety.
Some have the potential to punish people for being poor or uneducated by attaching a lower risk to those with steady work and high levels of education.
The surveys can include more than 100 questions and explore a defendant’s education, family, income, job status, history of moving, parents’ arrest history, or whether he or she has a phone. A score is affixed to each answer and the result helps shape how the defendant will be supervised in the system.
“How easy would you say it is to acquire drugs in your neighborhood?” a convicted thief could be asked.
“How many prior sex offense arrests (with force) as an adult?” a sex offender could be asked. A bubbled answer sheet lists options ranging from zero to more than three.
The idea is to use data about past offenders to predict what current defendants with similar backgrounds might do when released from prison. A major push is to free up parole and probation officers to focus on those more likely to reoffend, instead of lower risk inmates.
“It is a vast improvement over the decision-making process of 20, 30 years ago when parole boards and the courts didn’t have any statistical information to base their decisions on,” said Adam Gelb, director of the Public Safety Performance Project at the Pew Charitable Trusts, which is working with the U.S. Justice Department on changes to the prison systems nationally.
Cost savings are significant. In Arkansas, a prisoner costs the state $63 a day. A parolee costs $2.
But the sexual assault case in Little Rock also points to shortcomings.
Before Thomas was released, the parole board assessed him as a high risk to commit more crimes. But a second risk assessment, conducted by the state’s community supervision agency, found him to be a low risk, Thomas told the AP. Thomas said he has no recollection of answering questions from the lengthy survey.
Not only were Thomas’s contradictory assessments never explained, but after he was arrested on charges of raping Diana Miller, he was assessed again. The AP doesn’t identify victims of sexual assault, but Miller, now 71, agreed to be identified by her middle and married names because she said it is important for her story to be told.
Stunningly, Thomas’ risk-rating decreased after the rape charge.
The reason for the difference? The state couldn’t figure out how old Thomas was when first arrested, according to Solomon Graves, a member of the state parole board.
In June 2013, Thomas said he wasn’t yet 25 when first arrested, a high-risk factor, Graves said. The following year, Arkansas criminal history reports listed Thomas as having been in his late 30s when first arrested, so Thomas’s risk-rating was lowered. In a letter to the AP, Thomas said he was 19 when he was first arrested.
The calculations for determining probation conditions are often just as bewildering.
In February 2014, an Arkansas consultant said a majority of male parolees and probationers were classified as low risk by the state’s Department of Community Correction but 46 percent were rearrested within 18 months — “creating a potentially dangerous situation for public safety,” consultant JFA Associates LLC concluded.
“Virtually any recidivism reduction plan can be helpful,” said U.S. Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., who favors changes in prison policies.
Scott co-sponsored legislation in the last Congress that called for using risk assessment surveys for the federal prison population. “I think you ought to have some assessment and do the best you can and keep updating it based on the research. But you ought not be afraid of a system that’s working on average because of one anecdote.”
___
“Garbage in, garbage out”
Jurisdictions use dozens of different surveys that vary in the kinds of questions asked and how they are used. The Justice Department is helping bankroll this movement by providing millions of dollars to help states develop and roll out changes.
“We really consider them to be a cornerstone or a foundational piece of what we can accomplish,” said Ruby Qazilbash, associate deputy director for policy in the Bureau of Justice Assistance.
The goal is ultimately to save money, since states and counties spend some $92 billion a year on corrections.
But in most cases, the surveys can only work if the rest of the judicial system is working properly.
In September, that gap played out in a juvenile courtroom in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.
There, a teenager faced sentencing for a charge of aggravated battery with bodily harm stemming from an incident one year earlier over a neighbor’s dog. The neighbor let his dog out without a leash, and the barking dog ran toward the teen’s father. The teen’s dad told the dog to go away, upsetting the dog’s owner. Curses and threats followed. The dog owner walked away, then turned back toward the teen’s dad and took his shirt off. When the teen’s father called the police, his son joined the fracas and stabbed the dog owner, police said.
The teen was given a 128-item questionnaire called the Positive Achievement Change Tool, or PACT, standard for juvenile cases in Florida. He was deemed a low risk to commit further crimes. The AP does not generally name juveniles charged with crimes.
The survey asked about his history of school expulsions, views on the value of education, whether his parents had been arrested and whether his friends had committed crimes.
One answer helping earn him the low score: getting credit for having a good group of friends.
But when the prosecutor, Maria Schneider, dug into the defendant’s background, she found that his circle of “friends” had attempted a drive-by shooting of his house because they said he owed them money.
The assessment “is completely flawed,” Schneider said in court. “They were obviously depending just on the information this young man was providing himself,” she said.
She believed the teen was moderate to high-risk, worthy of detaining under a residential program. The judge sentenced him to such a program, where teens are supervised 24 hours a day, but not held behind bars. At low risk, as the survey suggested, he would have received probation.
The case is a perfect example of “garbage in, garbage out,” Schneider said in an interview. “I continue to see where the PACT does not reflect the reality.”
Corrections systems always have been plagued by inaccurate information, said Sean Hosman, founder of Assessments.com, the company that, in collaboration with Florida, fashioned the survey.
Even so, he said, the assessments are an improvement over past practices and help defendants get a fair shot.
“Too often,” Hosman said, “we would do a gut check or you’d use intuition … or assess them based on the color of their skin, or the fact that we knew their brother and they went through here before.”
In California, a public defender in San Joaquin County, Christine Kroger, said she is not seeing much improvement. She has had trouble even getting access to the surveys conducted on her juvenile clients.
“You feed all this information into a computer and it spits out what should happen to this child,” Kroger said.
In Kentucky, the surveys have helped decide which defendants should be released before trial, said Ed Monahan, Kentucky’s public advocate.
In his state, Monahan has seen a 3 percent increase in the number of defendants released before trial with “no adverse consequence to appearance or criminal behavior.”
These tools are also used by the parole board, but Monahan said he has been less impressed with the outcomes.
Of inmates who were eligible for parole and assessed to be a low risk of committing future crimes, only 60 percent are being released, Monahan said. “Millions of dollars that could be saved there — that’s not being done,” he said. The state’s parole board did not respond to questions about the discrepancy.
___
Questions of Potential Bias
The surveys have been largely confined to parole and probation decisions, but they increasingly are being used for sentencing.
One 2013 study said at least one court system in 20 states is using these questionnaires at some stage of sentencing. In some states, such as Michigan, the tools are used statewide.
Offenders in Michigan have been assessed since 2007 when they go to prison. Now the risk assessment is incorporated into a report given the judge before sentencing. Among the 135 questions:
—In the last 12 months before this incarceration, how often did you move?
—Was one of your parents (or parent figure who raised you) ever sent to jail or prison?
—In the last couple of years before this incarceration, how many of your friends/acquaintances had ever been arrested?
Sonja B. Starr, a University of Michigan law professor who wrote the 2013 study, said the surveys could punish people for being poor.
“They are about the defendant’s family, the defendant’s demographics, about socio-economic factors the defendant presumably would change if he could: Employment, stability, poverty,” Starr said. “It’s basically an explicit embrace of the state saying we should sentence people differently based on poverty.”
In a sense, the justice system has taken a page from the insurance industry, using data to assess risk.
“This is a way to put a blood pressure cuff on the guy and say, ‘This is what the data show. Now what are we going to do for the patient?'” said Thomas A. Powell, a forensic psychologist in Vermont, which uses an assessment tool called VASOR for sex offenders.
The Justice Department’s position on the tools has been inconsistent. On one hand, it’s funding them, and on the other, the department is putting on the brakes.
“Criminal sentences must be based on the facts, the law, the actual crimes committed, the circumstances surrounding each individual case, and the defendant’s history of criminal conduct,” U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder told the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers in August. “They should not be based on unchangeable factors that a person cannot control, or on the possibility of a future crime that has not taken place.”
The Justice Department cautioned the U.S. Sentencing Commission, which sets national policies, about relying too much on the new surveys. But jurisdictions are sorely tempted to test new systems that could save billions.
For instance, North Carolina could save $560 million by 2017, a Justice Department report concluded. Between 2011 and 2014, the North Carolina prison population decreased by more than 3,000 people, according to the state. Overhauls, including the use of risk assessments, have saved the state nearly $84 million, and it plans to use $32 million of those savings for community treatment programs.
___
A low-risk serial killer
Texas has been widely praised for overhauling its prison system — including use of surveys — in ways that helped drive down prison populations by more than 9 percent between 2007 and 2012, according to the Texas state figures.
The case of Darren Vann, however, exposed deadly flaws.
In 2004, Vann, then 33, grabbed an ex-girlfriend in a chokehold, doused her with gasoline, threatened to light her on fire and dragged her through an alley, according to court documents. He spent about one month in jail. His charge was downgraded to a misdemeanor, and he was sentenced to a year in jail, which he served on probation. The original presiding judge in his case was kicked off the bench about six months after Vann’s sentence because of a backlog of cases, the state’s supreme court said.
Vann violated his probation in 2005 and was to spend 12 days in jail. But it was unclear whether he did. Court records show a hearing scheduled for November of that year was canceled.
Four years later, Vann landed in jail again, this time for raping a woman in Austin, Texas.
When he completed his sentence in 2013, Texas performed an assessment on Vann, as it does on all sex offenders. Vann refused to take the three surveys that Texas typically uses. An employee filled out a 10-question survey, called Static-99R, to score Vann’s likelihood that he would commit another sex crime. Vann scored a 1 — the lowest risk — on a scale of 1 to 6. His assessment predicted only a 3.8 percent chance he would commit a future sex crime in the next five years.
But that was only if the answers to the questions were actually true.
One of the questions asked whether Vann had a previous sex offense. Because Texas had no record of his 2004 crime, a criminal history check noted in the survey indicated he had a clean record.
Had Vann scored higher on the Static-99R, Texas would have sent postcards to the community where he was living — if he was living in Texas. But Vann moved to Indiana after his release.
About one year later, 19-year-old Afrika Hardy was found dead in a Motel 6 bathtub 20 miles southeast of Chicago.
Vann had found her through an online escort ad, calling himself “Big Boy Appetite.”
According to police, Vann said he had sex with Hardy on Oct. 17 then things got rough. Wearing white gloves, he strangled Hardy with his hands and an extension cord, he told investigators. Vann was arrested after police traced him through cellphone records.
In custody, Vann confessed to the killing, and also told police he murdered six other women, directing them to abandoned homes in Gary, Indiana, where the bodies lay. Under a pile of tires and teddy bears at one home was the body of 35-year-old Anith Jones, who had gone missing earlier that month.
It was unclear how many of the women had died after Vann had taken the Static-99R.
Experts say that the risk-and-needs assessment tools should be evaluated every few years. Texas, which started using the instrument that evaluated Vann in 2000, is just now doing this, state spokesman Jason Clark said.
“States and localities and all the jurisdictions that are working on risk assessment right now, they’re in different places with respect to their ability to implement a good risk assessment,” Gelb said. “But it’s absolutely critical that they do.”
___
Crowded prisons
With more than 2.2 million people in jails and prisons across the country, the U.S. leads the world in incarceration, ahead of both China and Russia, according to the International Centre for Prison Studies. Successful changes in some states means lawmakers are considering changes for the federal system, too.
“We know that our prisons are overcrowded, and pretty much everyone agrees that recidivism, the percentage in which people repeat crimes, is way too high,” said U.S. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas. He cited a national recidivism rate of about 68 percent within three years, a figure from a 2014 Justice Department estimate of prisoners released in 30 states.
Cornyn and U.S. Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse, a Rhode Island Democrat, reintroduced legislation this month that would require the use of a risk assessment tool in the federal prison system.
“We’ can’t simply incarcerate our way to public safety,” Whitehouse said. “We have to be smart.”
There is a separate bill in the House that would also require risk assessments for the federal prison population.
Which risk assessment survey would be used and how it would be applied is a subject of debate.
Despite problems with the tools in Arkansas, the Justice Department in 2013 heralded the changes the state made to its corrections system.
Arkansas state Sen. David Sanders, however, said the changes have made the community less safe because it pushes responsibility to the parole and community supervision systems.
“Our parole system is absolutely dysfunctional,” said Sanders, an outspoken opponent of some of the changes in corrections policies made in Arkansas. He is pushing for more transparency about the use of the survey tools.
Even those who advocate for surveys acknowledged that they are imperfect.
Graves, the Arkansas parole board member, said over time the tools will become more dependable.
“We’re never going to have a 100 percent predictive tool,” he said. “We’ll never be there.”
___
Associated Press writers Alex Sanz in Atlanta and Tom Coyne in Crown Point, Indiana, contributed to this report.
___
Read the risk assessment for Indiana’s alleged serial killer here:
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1672461-vann-static-99.html
___
Read a letter from Arkansas parolee Milton Thomas to The AP here:
https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1675187-thomas-12-15-letter-1.html
___
Follow Eileen Sullivan on Twitter at www.twitter.com/esullivanap
Copyright 2015 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Black History
OP-ED: Black voters made history. They laid the groundwork for a Third Reconstruction.
BLACKPRESSUSA NEWSWIRE—Mississippi’s election of Scott Colom was the crown jewel of a Southern mobilization led by Black women and black-led organizations. The new governing majorities must use their power to protect fair representation, expand the right to vote, and deliver on the issues that brought people to the polls.
Black History
California Legislative Black Caucus Grows to 14, Women Hold 12 Seats
SAN DIEGO VOICE & VIEWPOINT — SAN DIEGO VOICE & VIEWPOINT — The California Legislative Black Caucus (CLBC) is preparing for a historic expansion following the Nov. 3 general election, with its membership set to grow from 12 to 14 members. This shift marks a significant milestone for political representation in the state, as Black women are expected to hold 12 of the 14 seats in the upcoming legislative session.
The California Legislative Black Caucus (CLBC) is preparing for a historic expansion, growing from 12 to 14 members following the Nov. 3 general election.
Black women are expected to hold 12 of the caucus’s 14 seats. The shift marks a significant milestone for Black women’s political representation in California and creates new opportunities to influence legislation, state resources and public policy.
Three incoming assemblymembers — Ayanna Davis (D-Compton), Jackie Elward (D-Rohnert Park) and Paula Swift (D-Westminster) — are expected to join the caucus when the new legislative session begins. Their victories, coupled with the departure of longtime Assemblymember Mike Gipson (D-Carson), will reshape the caucus’s membership and further elevate the role of Black women in the Legislature.
Davis, who won the 65th Assembly District seat representing Compton and surrounding communities, previously served on the Compton Unified School District Board of Education. An educator and former school principal with the Los Angeles Unified School District, Davis has focused much of her public service on education and opportunities for children and families. She will succeed Gipson, who is leaving the Legislature because of term limits.
Elward, who won the 12th Assembly District race in the North Bay, is a first-generation immigrant from the Democratic Republic of Congo. An educator, labor organizer and former mayor of Rohnert Park, she became the first Black woman elected to the city’s council in 2020. Her local government experience included policy related to affordable housing, homelessness and environmental justice, among other issues.
Swift defeated Republican incumbent Tri Ta in the 70th Assembly District race in Orange County. An educator and small business owner with a doctorate in Organizational Change and Leadership from the University of Southern California, Swift brings experience across nonprofit, government and private-sector organizations.
Although Davis replaces Gipson, Elward and Swift add two seats to the caucus, bringing its membership to 14. With all three incoming members being women, the caucus will move from nine women among its current 12 members to 12 women among next session’s 14 members.
The achievement builds on a milestone reached at the beginning of the 2025-26 legislative session, when women first became the majority of the CLBC. At that time, nine of the 12 members were Black women, the highest number in the organization’s history.
For LaNiece Jones, state president and CEO of Black Women Organized for Political Action (BWOPA-CA), the election results reflect generations of organizing and advocacy that have helped create opportunities for Black women in politics.
“We are celebrating an exciting moment for Black women’s political leadership across California. From local and regional offices to statewide leadership, these victories represent generations of Black women who have organized, advocated, mentored and opened doors for others to follow,” Jones told California Black Media (CBM).
Jones emphasized that electoral victories must translate into tangible improvements for Black communities.
“Winning elections is an important milestone, but building and sustaining political power is the greater mission. Representation must translate into meaningful influence, equitable policies, expanded opportunities, and tangible improvements in the lives of Black women, families, and our communities,” she said.
Jones also pointed to persistent barriers facing Black women seeking political leadership, including campaign financing, access to political networks, institutional support and opportunities for advancement.
The challenges extend beyond electoral politics, according to Black women leaders.
The 2025 State of Black Women in California Report, published by the California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute (CBWCEI), founded by Kellie Todd Griffin, documents persistent disparities in economic opportunity and social outcomes for Black women. Its findings reinforce the importance of ensuring that increased political representation addresses issues such as economic mobility, housing stability, health care and opportunities for Black women and girls.
“The number of Black women elected to public office across California in 2026 represents more than electoral victories.” said Todd Griffin, who is also president and CEO of CBWCEI.
“From city halls and school boards to the State Capitol and beyond, Black women are claiming their rightful place at decision-making tables,” continued Todd Griffin. “Every victory expands representation, strengthens our communities, and opens doors for the next generation of leaders. When Black women lead, California’s democracy grows stronger.”
The caucus is also preparing for a leadership transition. State Sen. Dr. Akilah Weber Pierson (D-San Diego), its outgoing chair, will pass the leadership position to Assemblymember Corey Jackson (D-Moreno Valley) for the 2027-28 legislative session.
In August, the caucus announced its incoming executive leadership team. State Sen. Laura Richardson (D-Inglewood) will serve as vice chair, Assemblymember LaShae Sharp-Collins (D-San Diego) as secretary, and Assemblymember Mia Bonta (D-Oakland) as treasurer.
Reflecting on her tenure, Weber Pierson said she was proud of the caucus’s work both inside and outside the Capitol.
“Serving as chair of the California Legislative Black Caucus has been an incredible honor. I am proud of the difference we have made not only through legislation, but by showing up in our communities and creating meaningful change for Black Californians,” Weber Pierson said in the caucus’s August announcement.
Founded in 1967, the CLBC was established to give Black lawmakers a unified voice in California government. Over nearly six decades, the caucus has helped advance legislation addressing racial equality, economic security, health care and criminal justice.
For BWOPA-CA, which has spent more than five decades developing Black women leaders and strengthening civic participation, the moment represents both progress and responsibility.
“Our success is not measured simply by how many seats we win, but by how many doors we open, how much opportunity we create, and how effectively we use our collective power to advance our communities,” Jones said.
Based on reporting by San Diego Voice & Viewpoint.
Black History
Ramon G. Griffin: A Morehouse Man on a Mission
WASHINGTON INFORMER — Ramon G. Griffin, an African-American history instructor at Thurgood Marshall Academy Public Charter School in Southeast D.C., was recently named the 2027 D.C. Teacher of the Year.
Shortly after becoming 2027 D.C. Teacher of the Year, Ramon G. Griffin appeared on WHUR 96.3 FM, where his story reached thousands of listeners, including a mother who he said later wrote him a two-page letter in request of guidance for her teenage son.
“I look forward to reaching out to her and assisting her in that process and that goal,” said Griffin, an African-American history instructor at Thurgood Marshall Academy Public Charter School in Southeast. “The meaning of this Teacher of the Year award is that I am able to have a voice and representation on a larger scale so that others can be inspired and so that I can help individuals. It’s my objective to work more closely with young teachers to aid them in their skill set, to make sure our children are being educated properly and effectively.”
On Oct. 26, D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser — flanked by D.C. State Superintendent Dr. Antoinette Mitchell, Ward 8 D.C. State Board of Education Representative Dr. LaJoy Johnson Law, and others — announced Griffin as 2027 D.C. Teacher of the Year during what several students, faculty and staff at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS thought was an assembly organized in celebration of the school’s 100% college acceptance rate since its inception.
“In my spirit, I can honestly say I knew I won,” Griffin told The Informer. “When she switched it up and said ‘I’m here for a teacher,’ the first thing that came to mind was that this may be it. Then she stated a quote from a documentary that was done on me last year, and she stated where I originate from, and I said I’m about to be awarded D.C. Teacher of the Year. That’s when it set in.”
Griffin, a self-described griot, has 13 years of teaching under his belt, seven of which have been at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS. That’s where he currently serves as an instructor of AP African-American Studies and African American History through Film and Music. Both courses, he told The Informer, allow him to engage students in storytelling.

Within a couple of months, Griffin’s endeavor to shape the minds of youth continues when Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS hosts yet another “Morehouse Day.” This event, held at several District schools, connects male students with members of the Morehouse Alumni Association Washington, DC Chapter, many of whom graduated from District public and public charter schools before pursuing higher education.
“We have Morehouse men who come in: those who are elders to me, those who were there during my tenure and those who are younger,” said Griffin, a member of Morehouse’s Class of 1998 and key influence in at least three Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS alumni’s matriculation to the HBCU. “What it shows is that we as Black men are not what they portray in the news. We’re not about bringing each other down. We’re about standing out, building, and making sure that our race is looked upon proudly, not for others, but for self and for the next generation.”
An Inside Look: ‘Morehouse Day’ at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS
The upcoming “Morehouse Day” at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS is scheduled to take place on Jan. 15, which would’ve been the 98th birthday of Morehouse alumnus the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. This intergenerational gathering also happens around the same time that Howard University men’s basketball team plays its home game against Morehouse College.
For Morehouse alumnus and “Morehouse Day” brainchild Ebbon Allen, it was a perfect storm that only Griffin could help make happen.
“Before we even knew that Ramon was going to be awarded and honored, we’ve been on ‘Morehouse Day’ as teammates for the last two years,” Allen told The Informer. “We definitely had a meeting within the last two or three months to designate ‘Morehouse Day’ for MLK’s birthday weekend. Ramon just shows the epitome of a Morehouse man: well-versed, well-traveled, and definitely educated.”
Speaking more about his fellow Morehouse alumnus, Allen said that Griffin has long put in the work to boost college enrollment among young Black men.
“He’s had a lot of young men going to attend Morehouse College,” Allen told The Informer. “We’re still trying to work on a pipeline to send more young men from Thurgood Marshall Academy down to Atlanta.”
Since the inception of “Morehouse Day” in 2021, Allen and other members of the Morehouse Alumni Association Washington, DC Chapter have spoken to more than 2,000 young men attending: Calvin Coolidge High School; Dunbar High School; Eastern Senior High School; Friendship Technology Preparatory High School; H.D. Woodson High School; Kelly Miller Middle School; and Ron Brown College Preparatory High School.
The upcoming “Morehouse Day” at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS will be the second seminar of its kind on school grounds. Allen said that students will delve into violence prevention, entrepreneurship, college and career readiness, and the scholarship application process. His goal, he said, centers on providing them space to imagine how to achieve their dreams.
“We wanted young Black men to understand that they can learn about self-advocacy and learn the value of being a Black male in today’s society,” Allen told The Informer. “There’s going to be a new [mayoral] administration so our young men need to get well-versed and become well-educated about their rights and the opportunities to create a space of learning about strong advocacy.”
Allen, who followed in his three uncles’ footsteps to attend Morehouse College, credited the HBCU with exposing him to the different caliber of Black men. He told The Informer that, like him and other Morehouse men, Griffin has embedded in him a passion for working hard and laying a foundation for those coming after him.
“Ramon Griffin sets the bar for other Black male educators about how much of an impact and difference they can make,” Allen told The Informer. “By coming to Thurgood Marshall Academy in Southeast Washington, D.C., he’ll make more young Black men…find out what it takes to get back in a positive light. You don’t always have to be an entertainer. You don’t always have to be in athletics, but you can take an education pathway and still be awarded for your service, commitment and dedication.”
Out of the Mouths of Babes
C’khai Morgan, a senior at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS, said he counts Morehouse College among his top choices for business management and human resource management, thanks to Griffin.
“He literally embodies the meaning of a Morehouse Man,” C’khai told The Informer. “You go in any classroom he ever had, you’re going to see something Morehouse. You catch him on a good day, he’s probably wearing a Morehouse sweater.”
C’khai, who also applied to Fayetteville State University, North Carolina Agricultural & Technical State University, and Temple University in Philadelphia, was a student in Griffin’s AP African-American Studies course last school year. On his way to scoring a 4 on the Advanced Placement exam and clinching college credits, he participated in Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS’ “My Brother’s Keeper” program, where he got to learn more about the man he now regards as an uncle.
“I started seeing a different side of Mr. Griffin that I never heard of,” C’khai said. “He always wants the best for somebody, but other students who lack maturity or just lack the understanding of his purpose would be like ‘Mr. Griffin be trying hard. He be pressed to get somebody in trouble.’ It reminded me that you can’t let somebody else’s opinions refer to someone as such.”
Students who take Griffin’s African-American History through Film and Music course take a trip through the Jim Crow, the Great Migration, and Harlem Renaissance, among other time periods, to understand how the blues genre originated from Africa, came into form during enslavement, and traveled with African Americans who moved into northern U.S. cities.
Although Griffin has a curriculum, he often deviates from it, as Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS student Kailani Marshall noted, by recounting his family history. She told The Informer about learning African-American history through stories of Griffin’s grandmother who migrated from Mississippi to Detroit, where he was born and raised.
“He makes sure that students actually retain the information and it’s entertaining as well,” said Kailani, a senior who hopes to study sociology either at Georgetown University, Howard University, Spelman College, or Temple University. “I can’t say that about a lot of classes. The way he teaches really allows students to understand topics fully.”

During her junior year, Kailani took Griffin’s AP African-American Studies and African-American History through Film and Music courses. She, too, scored a 4 on her AP exam, due to what she called Griffin’s demand for excellence.
“You can’t be mediocre. It’s not an option,” Kailani said about Griffin. “He’s passionate about instilling confidence and success into students. You can’t say that about a lot of teachers. He really is one of the few teachers who actually care for their students and care for their future.”
During Griffin’s first year of teaching AP African-American Studies at Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS, 87.5% of his students passed the AP exam. This feat follows other achievements at Dunbar High School, where he directed climate and culture, and at Kingman Academy Public Charter School, where he served as a founding member.
Even with Thurgood Marshall Academy PCS’ 100% college acceptance rate, Griffin acknowledged that it takes great effort to earn a bachelor’s degree. That’s what he said he emphasizes to his students as he shares his coming-of-age story and integrates writing and math enrichment into his assignments.
“You don’t want to be a 20-year-old counting on your fingers. You don’t want to be a 20-year-old starting a sentence and ending it at the end of the page with one period,” Griffin said. “You just have to put in the work, and I give them examples of times during my high school years and during my college years. Whatever you want in life, you can have. You definitely will accomplish it, but you have to have a plan. It’s not going to be given to you.”
Based on reporting by Washington Informer.
Black Press
‘It’s as if He Doesn’t Exist’: In Mississippi, People Jailed Months Without Formal Charges
TEXAS METRO NEWS — In the capital city of Jackson, Mississippi, hundreds of defendants remain behind bars for months or even years without being formally charged with a crime. A new investigative analysis has revealed a systemic crisis in Hinds County, where individuals are often stuck in an indefinite legal limbo known as “unindicted” status.
In the capital city, hundreds of defendants wait in jail for an indictment, sometimes as long as a year or more.
When Vicki Sands learned that her son, Carson, was in a county jail near Jackson, Mississippi, more than 600 miles away from her home in North Carolina, she felt, at first, a strange kind of relief.
Months before his arrest, he left Asheville, launching on a road trip with a new acquaintance he had met in the mountain city’s street-life scene. The journey had ended with a falling out in the Deep South that left Carson homeless.
“I was glad he was off the streets,” said Vicki Sands in an interview with The Marshall Project. “I was glad he was out of the woods.”
ADVERTISEMENT
That feeling didn’t last long.
Since an initial appearance before a judge on Nov. 3, just days after his Halloween night arrest last year, Carson Sands has not been inside a courtroom again. No attorney has requested a preliminary hearing or filed a motion to reduce his $300,000 bond on charges stemming from an alleged gas station robbery. There’s been no routine status conference where a judge might probe the reason for delays and prod prosecutors to move things along. He has not been indicted, convicted, or sentenced — but is stuck in an indefinite legal limbo.
“It’s as if he doesn’t exist,” his mother said.
As of June 30 of this year, Sands was one of 131 people being held for more than six months without an indictment: 56 of whom had been held for more than a year, an analysis by The Marshall Project found.
This article was published in partnership with The Howard Center for Investigative Journalism, an investigative reporting unit and early-career journalism training program based at the University of Maryland Philip Merrill College of Journalism, which is supported by the Scripps Howard Foundation.
ADVERTISEMENT
Such long periods of pre-trial incarceration with no formal charges from a prosecutor are almost unheard of in many other parts of the country, where prosecutors are given a limited amount of time to indict before a defendant must be released — 40 days in Florida, 60 days in Louisiana. In fact, Mississippi is one of only six states with no limits at all, according to a 2023 law review analysis.
In all, almost half of the people in custody at the end of June who had been held for at least 30 days on felony charges were not indicted, the analysis found.
State and local officials have argued and deflected blame about slow-moving criminal cases, backlogs and people literally getting lost in jail for years. A labyrinth of record systems, and questions about their accuracy, has often stymied those conversations. The Marshall Project’s findings are the first of their kind to be released publicly.
Critics say the analysis raises serious questions about whether the court system is depriving individuals of their constitutional right to due process before taking away their liberty.
Those critics include Brad McCullouch, a Hinds County assistant district attorney who was promoted to interim officeholder in July by the state’s governor.
ADVERTISEMENT
He went so far as to compare time spent in jail by some Hinds County prisoners to detention practices seen under authoritarian governments.
“This is not what we do as a country,” McCullouch said. “It’s not based on constitutional principles.”
McCullough touted his efforts to put more resources toward the grand jury process and to help secure the release of people from custody where he thinks appropriate. But he can’t run in next Tuesday’s special election because he doesn’t live in Hinds County, and is in office at most about six more weeks.
One of the five people running to replace McCullouch will help determine whether anything changes. Several have promised reforms, while others have not made it a central focus of their campaign.
Meanwhile, for Carson and others, the wait continues.
ADVERTISEMENT
“Lost in the System”
Carson Sands’ journey into legal purgatory began on Halloween night 2025, when he walked into a Jackson gas station near LeFleur’s Bluff State Park. Far from home, he’d marked his 31st birthday just days earlier, on the streets and huddled in the woods.
Sands placed a water, an energy drink, and a Cayman Jack beverage on the counter. The clerk told him he couldn’t use an EBT card for the alcohol, according to a police report written later. In a scene captured on security video, police said Sands pulled a can of bear spray from a backpack he was wearing. He put the items into the backpack, threatened to rifle through the cash register, and then displayed a knife on his way out of the store with the drinks.
A Capitol Police officer found Sands and arrested him not far away, in some woods near a baseball field.
An arrest like this is only the beginning of a criminal case. In most jurisdictions, a prosecutor must next consider the charges lodged by law enforcement and then decide whether to pursue formal charges in court. In Mississippi, district attorneys must obtain an indictment from a grand jury to prosecute someone for a felony.
During Sands’ initial — and only — court appearance, on Nov. 3, the judge ruled that he would need to post a secured bond of $300,000 to be released from jail while waiting for the next steps in his case. Using a bondsman, that would typically require a cash payment of about $30,000 — a sum he doesn’t have the means to pay.
The inability to pay does not necessarily lead to indefinite detention in many other states. Instead, after a certain amount of time, people in these states can ask a judge to reduce their bond or to outright release them from jail without having to pay any cash.
In Texas, after 90 days, Carson Sands could have asked for a lower bond or to be released without paying any money at all by the end of January.
There are constitutional reasons that many states put time limits on pre-trial detention, but also practical considerations. When a case stalls waiting for an indictment, victims must wait for resolution to their cases. Evidence can go stale or even be missing, making it harder for prosecutors to win a once solid case or for the accused to defend themselves. Defendants with few financial resources, like Sands, are forced to sit out the long wait times in a dangerous jail, while defendants with greater financial means get to spend that time at home.
This gray zone of detention without legal limits sits at the intersection of multiple dysfunctional systems stretched beyond their limits in Hinds County — including a decrepit and deadly jail under federal receivership and a public defender’s office still reeling from a staffing and caseload crisis.
But it’s the district attorney’s office — rocked by recent scandals — that is responsible for taking cases to the grand jury to seek an indictment. It’s also the office most subject to immediate oversight by voters, through next week’s special election. The office has been operating under an interim leader since July, when the previous prosecutor, Jody Owens, resigned as part of a plea deal in a federal corruption case.
Amid this tangle, Vicki Sands has found it very difficult to determine basic facts about her son’s detention, or to discern how to help. She considered trying to file a habeas corpus petition — which can be used to challenge the basis for someone’s detention — but doesn’t even know how to start.
“Carson is simply lost in the system,” said his mother. “He hasn’t been convicted, and yet he is detained going on a year with no end in sight.”
One Day in Court
Over the course of this year, as The Marshall Project conducted its analysis, a reporter spent several days in the county court. The reporter saw a series of unindicted defendants appear before a judge for a thicket of initial appearances, preliminary hearings, bond reductions and status hearings.
Felony cases in Mississippi must move through a series of different courts that don’t always intersect. In Hinds County, the county court is a frequent venue where attorneys bring motions and arguments on behalf of defendants without indictments. But with only a single judge hearing these cases, this is a major chokepoint.
As of April 15, Carson Sands had already been jailed for almost six months. His mother worried he was deteriorating within a dangerous and overwhelming environment. The lights in the jail were always on. A TV blared. She couldn’t mail him books, which had long been a source of calm to him. She sent meditation guides and other reading material through the jail messaging system, but some of her messages were blocked.
“He does not belong in prison,” Vicki had written around this time to a reporter with The Marshall Project. “He needs behavioral health treatment. He needs support for his psychiatric needs. Instead, he is in an environment that is crushing and traumatizing him.”
Carson — yet again — did not make it onto Judge Johnnie McDaniels’ slate of felony cases that day.
But several other people did, people just like him –– arrested, jailed, and simply waiting. Court officials called the case of LaShanti Esco. She’d been arrested last August on serious charges — armed carjacking and armed robbery. She faced a $1 million bond.
As the case was called, Wendy Wilson White, an assistant district attorney, said that the proceedings were moot — the case had finally been indicted, she said, paving the way for a formal arraignment in a higher court.
But Judge McDaniels saw a problem as he flipped through the papers in front of him. He’d heard this claim before.
“It is April,” he said. “The same representation was made in January. Why wasn’t an indictment that occurred in January filed by now? What would be the explanation?”
That can sometimes happen when law enforcement can’t locate a defendant to serve the papers. But Esco had been in the county’s custody the entire time.
“I don’t know that I have an explanation,” White said.
Ultimately, the indictment wasn’t served on Esco until about five days after the hearing, according to court records. It had only been signed by a grand jury that month, not in January.
White is one of five candidates now running in a special election to be the next district attorney in Hinds County.
White told The Marshall Project last week that she will never knowingly misrepresent a case to a judge and emphasized that when handling a case in court, she sometimes has limited information immediately available to her.
“I’m representing the state, and I have to take accountability when there are shortcomings in a case,” White said.
Next up was Jeremy Jordan, arrested in August 2025 on a drug possession charge. Jordan was held without bond due to prior charges from 2022 and 2023 that were still open and not indicted.
That meant, his attorney said, that Jordan had been in jail for 237 days with three criminal charges and not a single indictment on any of them.
In at least some of the cases, the defense attorney said, prosecutors were waiting on results from the state crime lab.
“We know the issues with the state crime lab,” McDaniels said. “Surely three or four years is enough time to get something back?”
McDaniels set a secured bond for $75,000 for Jordan — still a high bond. Jordan stayed in jail for months more, and in June submitted his own motions to dismiss the case for violation of due process.
The cases continued. Adetdrick Burton had been held almost a year on a murder charge and a $1 million bond, with no indictment.
“This case has not been presented to a grand jury,” said White, the assistant district attorney. “The DA’s office is not in possession of the file. The DA’s office requires, or prefers, to have the completed investigative file.”
In response to a question from the judge, White could not say whether the file had been requested from law enforcement by the DA’s office.
“A case is not solved just because an arrest is made,” said McDaniels. “When I’m being told more than a year later that you don’t know what stage a case is at, that should be troubling to us all.”
Next up was Justin Porter, held 609 days without an indictment on home burglary charges. White acknowledged the long delay in securing an indictment, but urged caution, alleging that the burglary in question had been carried out, she claimed, as “an attempt to terrorize the victims.”
“Surely there is an explanation why a defendant charged with attempted burglary of a dwelling has been detained for 609 days without being indicted,” McDaniels asked White. “There has to be an explanation.”
“That’s definitely a good question,” White said. “I don’t know that the state is prepared to offer an explanation that would be satisfactory.”
When cases stall like this, there are several possible reasons in play. Sometimes law enforcement makes an arrest but, as White suggested in court, simply does not turn over the file to the prosecutors, leaving those prosecutors without evidence to present to a grand jury. Sometimes the case has been forgotten, and the district attorney’s office simply hasn’t asked for it. Other times, the investigation may still be ongoing, even after an arrest has been made, or officers are waiting on forensic tests or other evidence.
But even when prosecutors don’t have an explanation at hand, or when defense attorneys haven’t given a case much attention, an area’s senior circuit judge has a responsibility under the state’s rules of criminal court: They must monitor the circumstances and release conditions of people detained in the local jail.
Senior Circuit Judge Winston Kidd and McDaniels, whom Kidd has designated to oversee felony cases before an indictment, did not respond to questions from The Marshall Project about how they handle review of the jail lists.
This requirement was written to prevent people from falling through the cracks, said William Waller Jr., a retired chief justice of the Mississippi Supreme Court who helped write the state’s rules of criminal procedure.
“That was the whole purpose for it,” said Waller. “It was supposed to be a safety net to catch cases.”
A Maze of Faulty Data
A month before Carson Sands was arrested, a jail operations consultant based in Maryland named Wendell France took over management of Hinds County’s Raymond Detention Center on the order of a federal judge.
That followed a decade of litigation brought by the U.S. Department of Justice over unending constitutional violations inside the county’s jail — widespread brutality, deaths and beatings at the hands of other prisoners, rampant contraband, open sewage, and poor or nonexistent medical care.
Once France began to examine the roster of detainees, he noticed something that alarmed him: Significant numbers of people in the jail were held only based on an arrest charge, with no indictment.
He dispatched a letter to local justice system officials, including Owens, who was then the DA. A former civil rights litigator, Owens ran for office in 2019, promising to be a “decarceral prosecutor.”
“I am writing to formally request your office’s immediate attention to the status of pre-trial detainees who have been held without indictment for extended periods,” France wrote to Owens in an Oct. 10, 2025 letter. “These are not merely administrative concerns but fundamental constitutional violations that expose the county to significant legal liability.”
As he had done before when similar concerns had surfaced, Owens responded by pointing out that jail rosters supplied by local jail administration are often riddled with errors.
“I am committed to reducing the delays for criminal detainees wherever possible, but caution you that the conclusions you have drawn in your correspondence are based on inaccurate data,” Owens wrote.
Owens also warned that law enforcement agencies, and not his office, often drive delays by failing to complete investigations promptly, even after an arrest has been made. Those agencies, Owens said, do not quickly turn over files to the DA’s office and sometimes do not even notify the office of cases that are open or arrests that have been made.
Nine months later, Owens resigned as part of a plea deal with federal prosecutors on conspiracy charges involving a bribery scheme.
Not long after these letters were dispatched, an assistant district attorney was also sounding the alarm, claiming that management of the grand jury process had fallen into near complete disarray.
“Cases are lost, defendants are lost, indictments have errors, hundreds of cases have been presented to the Grand Jury but never turned in,” wrote Gwen Agho in December 2025, according to an email she provided.
Agho is also now running for district attorney in Hinds County.
Locally, the accuracy of jail and court records has been a flashpoint in long-running clashes over jail crowding and case delays. Money from the state flowed into Hinds County beginning in 2022 to help reduce a pandemic-linked backlog, but local officials could not reach consensus about where the backlog was. This disagreement was driven, in part, by jail systems, court records, and case management that don’t talk to each other, said State Public Defender André de Gruy.
He identified unindicted cases as a key problem, but acknowledged he was dealing with jail lists widely known to be faulty, with errors in case numbers and indictment status. He didn’t have the resources to laboriously correct and verify those lists line by line.
But that’s exactly what The Marshall Project did.
The news organization started with a list provided by the county of the 848 people in custody on June 30 and then excluded people who had been there for less than 30 days — which is within detention norms nationwide — as well as people held on suspected or confirmed probation violations or other kinds of post-sentencing matters. The analysis also excluded people likely being held on misdemeanor charges and those under the age of 18 when they were arrested. That left 628 held in custody while facing criminal charges.
The Marshall Project examined several thousand pages of public court records, obtained through the Mississippi Electronic Courts portal, including dockets and filings, to match public indictments or circuit court cases to people detained at the jail. Almost half did not have any.
Even those who were indicted while in jail had often waited months for it to finally happen. More than two-thirds of the people who were still waiting for an indictment on June 30, or who had been indicted while held, had gone three months or more without an indictment.
How long had people in the Hinds County jail waited for an indictment?
Hundreds of people who were in jail in Hinds County, Miss., on June 30 of this year had waited more than 30 days in custody without receiving an indictment. Most of them waited more than 90 days.

McCullouch said The Marshall Project’s analysis reached findings similar to those his staff conducted after he took over the office in July.
In a letter to France in September, he touted the role of his office in securing release for 59 people held on non-violent charges. By October, McCullouch told the county’s Board of Supervisors that number had risen to 74.
He called this the “low-hanging fruit” that needed to happen quickly to relieve pressure on the jail before a more careful sifting of cases with violent charges follows. That work will take longer, he said, because of the potential stakes for broader public safety.
In doing that careful sifting, McCullouch — and White, speaking separately about her plans if elected — also touted the significance of new funding from the county for an additional assistant prosecutor’s position.
But the maze of often-faulty data doesn’t help either, said McCullouch.
Justice system officials should have access to reliable, current data of the sort that it took The Marshall Project weeks to produce, said Andrew Davies, research director with the Deason Criminal Justice Reform Center at Southern Methodist University.
“Hinds County urgently needs better systems for tracking this information,” Davies said. “Without them, courts and jails lack the tools they need to deliver justice and treat people with dignity.”
The interlocking nature of the problem, cutting across different systems and different branches of government, means it’s hard to identify one point of failure that can be easily fixed. But it also means that there are several people empowered to push solutions or force the issue onto the agenda — including judges, legislators, and the local district attorney.
And that’s where, McCullouch said, regardless of what judges or police detectives do, or how faulty the jail data happens to be, a prosecutor has power — if they will use it.
Sometimes, he said, that means taking a case with no file to the grand jury, expecting the grand jury to decline an indictment.
So what happens next for Sands?
Earlier this month, The Marshall Project asked McCullouch about the status of the case and why there’d been such a long delay in securing an indictment.
McCullouch turned around in his chair and faced his computer — “You said Sands?” he asked, double-checking as he typed — opening the system prosecutors use to track case files submitted by law enforcement agencies.
There was nothing for Carson’s case. Just an empty screen. McCullouch told The Marshall Project he’d never heard of the case until the news outlet asked. He said his office would try to find out more and take some action.
Capitol Police turned the case file over to prosecutors the next day, according to a spokesperson for the agency.
After 349 days in jail, Sands had been found.
In this article:‘It’s as if He Doesn’t Exist’: In Mississippi, People Jailed Months Without Formal Charges Written By Texas Metro News
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
You May Also Like
News
‘It’s as if He Doesn’t Exist’: In Mississippi, People Jailed Months Without Formal Charges
When Vicki Sands learned that her son, Carson, was in a county jail near Jackson, Mississippi, more than 600 miles away from her home…
Texas Metro NewsNovember 1, 2026 Advertisement
Based on reporting by Texas Metro News.
Black History
Carolyn Hugley Could Become Georgia’s First Black Woman House Speaker
ATLANTA DAILY WORLD — Georgia House Democrats have selected State Representative Carolyn Hugley as their nominee for speaker, positioning the Columbus legislator to potentially become the first Black woman to lead the chamber. The nomination follows a shift in party control for the first time in over two decades.
Georgia House Democrats have selected State Rep. Carolyn Hugley as their nominee for speaker, positioning her to become the first Black woman to hold the position.
According to CBS News Atlanta, Hugley, a Democrat representing Columbus, was chosen Thursday (November 12) after her party secured control of the House for the first time in more than two decades. The full chamber is scheduled to vote on her nomination January 11, 2027.
Hugley, who has served in the Georgia General Assembly since 1993, currently holds the position of House minority leader, CBS News Atlanta reported. If elected, she would succeed Republican Jon Burns, who has led the chamber since 2023.
During her time in the legislature, Hugley became the first Black lawmaker to serve as House minority whip, a position she held from 2003 to 2018, according to her website. She has also chaired the Legislative and Congressional Reapportionment Committee and the Women’s Legislative Caucus.
Her legislative work has included sponsoring bills addressing bullying, anti-stalking protections and protections for veterans’ widows, according to her official state biography.
Speaking at a press conference at the state Capitol Thursday, Hugley said Democrats must deliver on the opportunity Georgia voters had given them.
“We cannot settle for business as usual after all the what we’ve done to get here,” she said, according to Georgia Public Broadcasting. “We didn’t come this far to settle into new titles and new offices and get that new letterhead. We’re here because Georgia has given us the opportunity to deliver for them.”
Hugley’s potential election would also bring greater representation to one of the state’s most powerful political positions, which has historically been held by white men. The Courier News emphasized the significance of a Black woman from the Chattahoochee Valley reaching that level of leadership, particularly for young Black girls who rarely see people who look like them in positions of political power.
Republicans will retain control of the state Senate, meaning Democrats will need to work across party lines to advance their legislative agenda.
The Black Information Network is your source for Black News! Get the latest news 24/7 on The Black Information Network. Listen now on the iHeartRadio app or click HEREto tune in live.
The post Carolyn Hugley Could Become Georgia’s First Black Woman House Speaker appeared first on Atlanta Daily World.
Based on reporting by Atlanta Daily World.
Black History
Debunking the Myth That Europeans Alone Plotted Africa
THE CAROLINIAN — Following the United Nations’ recent adoption of a resolution endorsing more accurate global maps, scholars are reexamining historical misconceptions regarding the cartography of Africa.
THE CONVERSATION – After the United Nations adopted a resolution in September 2026 endorsing a map that more fairly represents the size of Earth’s landmasses, author and journalist Moky Makura of Africa No Filter – a main sponsor of the Correct the Map initiative – asked: “What else about Africa is the world underestimating that’s also hidden in plain sight?”
It is a fair question.
The initiative brought attention to the way continents are distorted by projections that display our rotund planet on two-dimensional maps, something that has long made Africa especially appear far smaller than it actually is. But it left another assumption untouched: that European maps of Africa – which became the basis of how we see African countries today – are based solely on the observations of the Europeans who made them.
As an expert on the map history of Africa, I know that this is a misconception which deserves rethinking. Recent research by myself and others on colonial-era mapping of West Africa demonstrates that much of the geographical information these maps show is based on African observations. It’s just that Europeans largely took the credit.
A line in the sand
Most African map traditions are undocumented or ephemeral. But ground and oral mapping was common in the pre-colonial period, and often highly valued. European explorers relied upon these indigenous mapping practices during their travels and sometimes incorporated them into their own maps.
For example, sections of French explorer Henri Duveyrier’s 1861 map of the Sahara owed much to the maps drawn in the sand by his guide, Cheikh-‘Othmàn. Indeed, more than a third of Duveyrier’s map is based on information provided by local sources.
A common objective of mapping is to solve a spatial problem. Route mapping is all about finding one’s way between points A and B and determining the distances between them. For Europeans, it was important to know where African leaders resided or the most direct route to important trade centers.
When European explorers and soldier-surveyors inquired, African guides, interpreters and merchants described the road ahead and often drew these routes on the ground with a stick. Europeans valued African oral and ground-mapping practices for their contributions to knowledge; they were also useful for empire building.
In his 1892 travel memoir, French Navy Lt. Louis-Gustave Binger reproduced the plan of Niellé, a city in contemporary northern Ivory Coast that was drawn on the ground by his interpreter, Fofana Diawé.
Niellé’s chief prohibited Binger from visiting the town, making Diawé’s drawing particularly valuable. In another instance, Binger reports that an African intermediary placed varied lengths of straw on the ground to indicate the distances between localities in the Kong region.
In his exploration of the area between the Niger River and the Gulf of Guinea in the early 1890s, Navy Lt. Jean-Baptiste Marchand routinely collected route information from local inhabitants about places he could not visit. This “locally sourced route information,” as he described it, appears as dashed lines on his landmark map of the region. The routes of Marchand and other European explorers appear as solid lines.
When the total distance of all routes is calculated, African sources account for 65% of routes on Marchand’s map.
Thanks to African intermediaries guiding these military explorers, Binger discovered that the fabled Kong Mountains, which stretched across most 19th-century maps, did not exist.
And Marchand learned that the savanna penetrated more deeply into the rainforest in south-central Ivory Coast. The elimination of the imaginary Kong Mountains and knowledge of a shorter travel distance through the dense tropical forest accelerated French colonization of the region.
But this practice of displaying locally sourced route information on European maps was debated among European geographers and military officers. Some mapmakers refused to display African mapping because it did not follow the standards of scientific cartography.
They argued that the geographical information was based on hearsay rather than measurement. Others, particularly military officers trying to expand colonial boundaries, appreciated locally made maps’ practical value. Embedded in this debate was the self-claimed civilizing mission ideology underpinning colonialism, which assumed the superiority of European knowledge. The dashed lines suggest that locally sourced information was tentative and would eventually be replaced by solid lines based on European measurements.
Filling in the blanks
The appearance of blank spaces on maps is typically seen as demonstrating the scientific standard of accuracy: Cartographers don’t show what we don’t know.
Blank spaces were also viewed as instrumental to imperial expansion. That’s because they suggested vacant areas open to colonization.
The common denominator of both views is that Europeans determine what is shown and not shown on maps of Africa. But a closer look at explorers’ and soldier-surveyors’ reports indicates that blank spaces often emerged from the refusal of African authorities to allow Europeans to travel through their territory.
Wisely, these African rulers understood the ultimate goals of European soldier-surveyors – to map the road to colonial conquest. In the memoir of his exploration of contemporary Mali, Ivory Coast and Burkina Faso, Binger explained the blank spaces on his four-sheet map as deriving from his lack of “a good guide and a travel permit [from African authorities].”
To try to overcome this lack of access, colonial officials employed Africans to explore and map. Traces of their little-known expeditions appear in late 19th- and early 20th-century compilation maps assembled by European mapmakers. The travel routes of two Senegalese explorers, Roger Panet in 1850 and Bou El Mogdad Seck around a decade later, appear in Hermann Habenicht’s ten-sheet map of Africa published in 1885-1886.
The central Africa mapping of two Africans working as Portuguese trade agents, Pedro Joao Baptista and Amaro José, is depicted on the “Kabébé” sheet of Régnauld de Lannoy de Bissy’s 63-sheet map of Africa.
The display of their itineraries in solid lines alongside those of Europeans indicates their equal treatment by Lannoy. Lannoy also used the dashed-line symbol to show locally sourced geographical information. More than two-thirds of the route information displayed in his 1882 Segou-Sikoro sheet stems from African mapping practices.
Both maps were used at the Berlin Africa Conference of 1884-85 to determine the boundaries of free trade zones in the Congo and Niger river basins.
The conference kick-started the “scramble for Africa” that was to last into the 20th century. Paradoxically, the maps that Africans helped construct were later used to divide their territories into European colonies.
Decades after decolonization, when we open the drawers of national archives, we find these remarkable maps with their solid and dashed lines. And map historians are finally acknowledging that these maps, cataloged as purely European achievements, are in fact hybrid productions that emerged from complex intercultural encounters. The evidence was hidden in plain sight.
Based on reporting by The Carolinian.
-
Black History1 week agoDon’t Pass the Torch. Expand the Circle.
-
Black Press6 days agoOP-ED: Closing the Next Digital Divide — Communities of Color Must Have a Voice in the AI Future
-
Featured1 week agoDemocratic Leadership Under Fire, Maxine Waters Challenged & Tyler Perry’s New Political Role 📱
-
Black History7 days agoNew NAACP Report Warns AI Could Deepen Health Disparities in Black Communities
-
Black History5 days ago“Blue Tsunami” Sweeps Georgia, Bottoms Makes History
-
Black History1 week agoNixon Unbought, Unbossed and Undeterred Following U.S. Senate Defeat – Free Press of Jacksonville




